Table 9

Employment Outcomes—Robustness Checks

NEver Returned to WorkCumulated EmploymentCumulated Labor Income
Panel A: Baseline DiD
506,919−0.014***−13.511***−907.011***
(0.003)(2.277)(197.623)
Mean 2012 spring0.82845228,668
Panel B: Specification Checks
Baseline—No Control Variables506,919−0.013***−12.648***−677.401***
(0.003)(2.312)(229.431)
Linear506,919−0.010***−11.888***−853.363***
(0.003)(2.446)(213.857)
Quadratic506,919−0.011***−12.029***−810.856***
(0.003)(2.484)(216.321)
Panel C: Observation Period: Births in. . .
July and August excluded443,253−0.015***−14.692***−916.254***
(0.003)(2.436)(211.334)
Mean 2012 spring0.82945328,716
May to October only292,160−0.015***−13.255***−845.956***
(0.004)(3.002)(260.605)
Mean 2012 spring0.82645128,599
June to September only181,110−0.012**−10.083***−649.802**
(0.005)(3.822)(330.319)
Mean 2012 spring0.82444728,262
Panel D: Accounting for Legal Entitlement to Slot in Childcare
Controlling for slot entitlement (months)506,919−0.014***−13.499***−840.248***
(0.003)(2.350)(204.045)
Mean 2012 spring0.82845228,668
Slot entitlement + childcare coverage502,948−0.013***−13.359***−828.215***
(0.003)(2.355)(204.722)
Mean 2012 spring0.82845228,668
Placebo 2011325,604−0.004−2.955−144.233
(0.003)(2.498)(213.493)
Mean 2011 spring0.81344527,681
DiDisc506,919−0.010−9.703*−742.962*
(0.006)(5.191)(449.229)
Panel E: Excluding Observations above the Social Security Contribution Threshold
Below threshold479,700−0.014***−13.602***−811.177***
(0.003)(2.348)(186.495)
Mean 2012 spring0.82244626,145
Panel F: Effects 48 Months after Birth (For Births before 2013 Only)
48 Months after birth414,437−0.007***−15.330***−1,080.891***
(0.002)(3.081)(278.040)
Mean 2012 spring0.87766542,538
  • Source: Own calculations based on BEH data for for children born between March 2008 and December 2013, West Germany only.

  • Notes: Outcomes are measured 36 months after birth in Panels A–E. Cumulated employment is measured in days, cumulated labor income in euros. Controls in Xi are district‐level fixed effects (Kreise), age at birth dummies (<25, 25–30, 30–35, 30–40, >40), daily wage prior to birth dummies (<20, 20–40, 40–60, 60–80, 80–100, 100–120, >120), tertiary education (dummy), dummies for missing values in either. Robust standard errors in parentheses. Significance levels: *p < 0.10, **p < 0.05, ***p < 0.01.