Table 8 Regression Discontinuity Estimates of Heterogeneous Effects of IPN Admission on ENLACE Subject Scores
(1)(2)(3)(4)(5)(6)(7)
Panel A
Score ≥ cutoff0.242***0.253***0.243***0.226***0.247***0.245***0.240***
(0.0357)(0.0324)(0.0419)(0.0425)(0.0345)(0.0407)(0.0423)
[0.00][0.00][0.00][0.00][0.00][0.00][0.00]
(Score ≥ cutoff) * (middle school GPA)−0.022−0.068−0.042
(0.0401)(0.0607)(0.0537)
[0.43][0.29][0.25]
(Score ≥ cutoff) * (parental education)−0.007−0.002
(0.0079)(0.0112)
[0.36][0.88]
(Score ≥ cutoff) * (change in commute due to admission)−0.006−0.007−0.005
(0.0048)(0.0049)(0.0052)
[0.24][0.09][0.33]
(Score ≥ cutoff) * change in mean HS peer COMIPEMS exam score due to admission)0.0020.003
(0.0036)(0.0037)
[0.27][0.29]
(Score ≥ cutoff) * (Student resides in Federal District)−0.013−0.086
(0.0558)(0.0763)
[0.73][0.31]
(Score ≥ cutoff) * (Middle school GPA) * (Change in commute due to admission)−0.007
(0.0056)
[0.15]
Observations12,10512,9268,1778,24512,1157,0018,172
Adjusted R-squared0.2550.2870.2480.2410.2570.2590.253
Mean of dependent variable 1 point below cutoff0.2860.2720.3400.3230.2840.3250.340
Bandwidth15.619.413.613.415.613.413.7
Interaction term from Lee upper bound exercisea−0.090*−0.006−0.0010.006−0.035
(0.051)(0.009)(0.005)(0.005)(0.080)
Interaction term from Lee lower bound exercise0.034−0.010−0.0070.0030.013
(0.045)(0.009)(0.005)(0.004)(0.078)
Panel B. Spanish Score
Score ≥ cutoff0.0580.0380.0530.0390.0500.0570.065
(0.0358)(0.0362)(0.0395)(0.0369)(0.0336)(0.0417)(0.0418)
[0.06][0.11][0.09][0.12][0.03][0.12][0.12]
(Score ≥ cutoff) * (middle school GPA)−0.107**−0.134**−0.092**
(0.0440)(0.0530)(0.0396)
[0.00][0.01][0.01]
(Score ≥ cutoff) * (parental education)0.0060.010
(0.0118)(0.0133)
[0.76][0.56]
(Score ≥ cutoff) * (change in commute due to admission)−0.015***−0.018***−0.007*
(0.0047)(0.0051)(0.0036)
[0.01][0.01][0.14]
(Score ≥ cutoff) * change in mean HS peer COMIPEMS exam score due to admission)0.006*0.005
(0.0032)(0.0035)
[0.05][0.13]
(Score ≥ cutoff) * (student resides in federal district)0.032−0.131*
(0.0807)(0.0772)
[0.53][0.07]
(Score ≥ cutoff) * (middle school GPA) * (change in commute due to admission)−0.017***
(0.0062)
[0.09]
Observations10,6879,7558,1848,80510,6937,4718,179
Adjusted R-squared0.1640.1540.1630.1600.1580.1740.173
Mean of dependent variable 1 point below cutoff0.1140.1330.1370.1360.1170.1620.137
Bandwidth14.113.914.114.214.114.014.1
Interaction term from Lee upper bound exercisea−0.174***0.003−0.012**0.009**0.010
(0.047)(0.013)(0.005)(0.004)(0.085)
Interaction term from Lee lower bound exercise−0.0140.007−0.015***0.007*0.066
(0.046)(0.013)(0.006)(0.004)(0.080)
  • Notes: Estimates are from local linear regressions, including separate linear terms for each of the 16 IPN cutoff schools, cutoff school-year fixed effects, and covariates whose interaction terms are included in the regression. Piecewise-linear terms in centered COMIPEMS score are interacted with the corresponding demeaned covariate in each column. Column 7 includes the interaction of the demeaned middle school GPA and change in commuting distance variables, and this measure’s interaction with piecewiselinear terms in centered COMIPEMS score. The edge kernel is used in each regression and in computation of the corresponding optimal Imbens–Kalyanaraman bandwidths. Standard errors clustered at the admitted high school level are in parentheses. Wild cluster bootstrapped p-values, clustered at the centered COMIPEMS score level, are in brackets.

  • * p < 0.10,

  • ** p < 0.05,

  • *** p < 0.01.

  • a Estimation of interaction terms obtained from bounding exercise is described in Section Vof the text.