Table 6

Robustness Checks

Dependent variable: Overall HSEE test scorePercent of teachers ofPercent of teachers with university degreePercent of teachers with informal trainingAverage years of teaching
Rank IIRank III/IV
Base result (from Table 5)
(1) Coefficient estimates 95 percent confidence interval0.76***
[0.43 – 1.10]
1.10***
[0.61 – 1.58]
0.06
[−0.09 – 0.20]
−0.45***
[−0.70 – −0.19]
−4.22***
[−6.30 – −2.14]
Robustness to omitted school characteristics
(2) Controls for school characteristics0.74***1.04***−0.02−0.54***−4.37***
Robustness to randomization and student transfers
(3) Controls for individual characteristics0.77***1.23***0.05−0.37***−4.86***
Adding transfer students
(4) 2 SLS0.86***1.04***0.07−0.28*−4.24***
      Overidentification test for 2SLS: Sargan statistic = 4.5, p-value = 0.21
Robustness to missing HSEE test scores
(5) Controls for missing scores0.51***0.68**0.27***−0.29**−2.86**
Alternative model specifications
(6) Weighted regression0.89***1.99***−0.11−0.61**−6.83***
(7) All controls0.64***0.87***0.14−0.33**−3.86***
  • 95 percent confidence intervals in brackets;

  • * Significant at 10 percent;

  • ** significant at 5 percent;

  • *** significant at 1 percent.

    All estimations include student gender and primary test score, parents’ education and income, primary school dummy variables, and selection channel fixed effects. In addition:

    • (2) Includes ratio of the number of libraries to 100 students, teacher-student ratio, and nonrandomized students’ parent income.

    • (3) Includes parents having a relative in the school, parental ideal for child final education level (6 levels), the number of Type A schools in application sequence, the average scores in 1999 of the first three choices, and the average percentage of teachers of Rank II and higher in the first three choices.

    • (5) Includes percentage of students with missing HSEE score and its square, relative score on last semester exam of students with missing score and those with observed scores.

    • (7) Includes all controls used in (2), (3), and (5).

  • (4) Instrumenting teacher characteristics with those of the schools in which the student should be enrolled had he not transferred.

  • (6) With weights inversely proportional to the estimated probabilities of not having a missing score.